Comment on the Communication TMThe Key to Solving the Protein-Folding Problem Lies in an Accurate Description of the Denatured State∫ by van Gunsteren et al.**
نویسندگان
چکیده
In a recent communication, [1] van Gunsteren et al. proposed that the folding of proteins is much easier than has been believed [2] because the number of accessible conformers in the denatured state is only on the order of 10 9 for a 100-residue protein, instead of on the order of 10 24 to 10 30 used in previous analyses. [3, 4] This would make it possible for a polypeptide chain to fold to the native state in about 1 s by a random search since the transition from one conformer to another requires about 1 ns. [5] Van Gunsteren et al. [1] based their argument on simulations ranging from 32 to 200 ns of the folding and unfolding of six b and a amino-acid peptides in methanol and water. For these peptides, the number of conformers found by them corresponds to 1.22 to 1.74 con-formers per torsional degree of freedom, in the same range as the value 1.33 we found [6] in Monte Carlo simulations with an implicit solvent model of a denatured 16-residue peptide that forms a b-hairpin in the folded state; the simple average of the number of conformers per torsion angle calculated by van Gunsteren et al. for the different peptides is 1.40. If the number of conformers scales exponentially with the number of amino acids, an estimate of 1.33 (1.40) conformers per backbone torsion angle leads to a denatured state for a 100-residue protein with 1.33 200 (1.40 200) 6 Â 10 24 (1.7 Â 10 29) accessible conformers, [3, 4] which is many orders of magnitude larger than the value (10 9) suggested by van Gunsteren et al. The essential question concerns not the number of conformers observed in the peptide studies, but the statement that the number of conformers ™does not grow exponentially with the length of the peptide∫ [p. 364/352 of ref. [1]]. It is the latter that leads to their optimistic conclusion concerning the simplicity of the protein folding problem. There is no evidence for or against this claim in their simulations. The peptides studied vary by only a factor of two in size; in fact, there is one short peptide (9 torsion angles) and the five others vary in length only between 16 and 21 torsion angles. Since the number of conformers shows essentially no correlation with the number of torsion angles (the Pearson linear correlation coefficient between the …
منابع مشابه
Structural Characteristics of Stable Folding Intermediates of Yeast Iso-1-Cytochrome-c
Cytochrome-c (cyt-c) is an electron transport protein, and it is present throughout the evolution. More than 280 sequences have been reported in the protein sequence database (www.uniprot.org). Though sequentially diverse, cyt-c has essentially retained its tertiary structure or fold. Thus a vast data set of varied sequences with retention of similar structure and fun...
متن کاملMistaking the Map for the Territory: What Society Does With Medicine; Comment on “Medicalisation and Overdiagnosis: What Society Does to Medicine”
Van Dijk et al describe how society’s influence on medicine drives both medicalisation and overdiagnosis, and allege that a major political and ethical concern regarding our increasingly interpreting the world through a biomedical lens is that it serves to individualise and depoliticize social problems. I argue that for medicalisation to serve this purpose, it would have to exclude the possibil...
متن کاملInnovation, Demand, and Responsibility: Some Fundamental Questions About Health Systems; Comment on “What Health System Challenges Should Responsible Innovation in Health Address? Insights From an International Scoping Review”
In this commentary on the exercise of Lehoux et al (this volume) I argue that in discussions on the current challenges of health systems, a better diagnosis of the health system is required. The cause of responsible innovation in health (RIH) requires a better understanding of the dynamics of health systems, in particular how innovation, demand, and responsibility are m...
متن کاملSome Notes on Critical Appraisal of Prevalence Studies; Comment on: “The Development of a Critical Appraisal Tool for Use in Systematic Reviews Addressing Questions of Prevalence”
Decisions in healthcare should be based on information obtained according to the principles of Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM). An increasing number of systematic reviews are published which summarize the results of prevalence studies. Interpretation of the results of these reviews should be accompanied by an appraisal of the methodological quality of the included data and studies. The critical a...
متن کاملThe Impact of Empathy Training on Social Problem Solving Skills in Female Students with Traumatic Experience
Background and Purpose: Human beings face many traumatic events throughout their lives with different consequences. Many children and adolescents experience stressful events during their developmental period, such as parental addiction or death of an elderly relative. Posttraumatic stress disorder is a complicated and chronic disorder that causes significant problems and disruptions in social a...
متن کامل